How to choose AI for writing
The best AI for writing fits the way you develop a draft. Decide whether you need help getting started, revising a draft you already have, or checking it before sharing. Use the AI tool finder and try two candidates with the same input. A specific brief will tell you more than asking for a generic article.
Choose a tool for your kind of revision
Claude is worth trying when you have a long brief and want to revise it in stages. Give it the intended audience, the decision you want them to make, and a sample of your writing. Ask for an outline before a full draft if the message still needs structure. When you revise, point to the sentences you want to keep so the next pass respects your intent. Anthropic's prompting guide gives examples for structuring instructions.
ChatGPT is a useful candidate if the draft pulls in multiple formats, such as a short dataset and an image. It can help you read the inputs and turn them into a coherent first draft. Check which parts of the finished text came from the source and which parts are inferences. OpenAI's capabilities guide explains available writing and file tools.
If you spend most of your day in Docs and Gmail, test Gemini where the draft will actually be edited. Check whether your Google account supports the features you need and try its suggestions on one existing document or email. A tool that fits where reviewers work can shorten the path from outline to feedback. Google's Workspace AI overview describes that integration.
Give both tools the same brief
Use a short assignment you recognize. For example, draft an email summarizing a product change after a meeting. Supply the audience, the decision behind the change, and one next action. Provide a small excerpt as a tone reference and say which facts must be kept exactly.
After the first draft, ask both tools for a revision with the same instructions. For example, ask them to shorten the opening, remove redundant claims, keep a sensitive qualifier, and end with one clear request. Compare the revisions to your original notes. Did one lose a condition, invent an example, or make the tone too formal?
Review the result the way your audience will
Check the first paragraph for purpose and context. Read the closing paragraph to see whether the requested action is clear. For every date, number, quote, or feature claim, find the corresponding source in your input. If you need help fact-checking the claims, try the process in the AI for research guide.
Watch how much editing remains after the revision round. Some drafts look polished but require substantial rework because the tool chose the wrong audience or neglected an important distinction. A short first draft that follows the brief can be easier to finish.
Keep the tool that improves the kinds of drafts you actually write. An AI that helps with internal emails might be less helpful with a researched article. Starting with two examples gives you a clearer basis for the choice.